Updated November 2026

All grain beer brewing gives home brewers the most control over flavor, color and body, but the right kit makes the first batch far less intimidating. This guide compares four all grain options based on product listings, brand reputation and common owner feedback, focusing on what is included, the batch style and how well each kit suits a specific skill level.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing KitTOP CHOICEBest overallMy Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing KitView on Amazon
  2. 2Christmas Ale Advanced All Grain 5 Gallon Home Brewing Beer IngredientBest for seasonal brewingChristmas Ale Advanced All Grain 5 Gallon Home Brewing Beer IngredientView on Amazon
  3. 3Northern Brewer Nut Brown Ale Extract Beer Homebrewing Recipe Kit, 5 GalBest for extract-curious beginnersNorthern Brewer Nut Brown Ale Extract Beer Homebrewing Recipe Kit, 5 GalView on Amazon
  4. 4Grain Mill Brewing for Grain Malt Barley, Malt Mill for Homebrew BeerBest for grain processingGrain Mill Brewing for Grain Malt Barley, Malt Mill for Homebrew BeerView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit Hazy IPA fans Full all grain ingredient set
Christmas Ale Advanced All Grain Kit Seasonal beer lovers Spiced holiday recipe
Northern Brewer Nut Brown Ale Kit Extract-curious beginners Malt extract base
Grain Mill Brewing Malt Mill Crushing your own grain Two stainless rollers

My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit

My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit | American Pale Ale Malt | Carapils Grain | Flaked Oats & Wheat | Azacca & Mosaic Pellet Hops | English Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing

My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit | American Pale Ale Malt | Carapils Grain | Flaked Oats & Wheat | Azacca & Mosaic Pellet Hops | English Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing

View on Amazon

Best for: Hazy IPA fans who want a complete all grain ingredient set.

This kit suits brewers who already have basic all grain equipment and want a single box of grain, flaked adjuncts, hops and yeast for a 5-gallon batch.

Pros

  • Includes grain, hops and yeast together
  • Recipe is built around a modern hazy style

Cons

  • Requires a mash tun and some equipment already on hand

View on Amazon

Christmas Ale Advanced All Grain 5 Gallon Home Brewing Beer Ingredient Recipe Kit by My Brew Supply

Christmas Ale Advanced All Grain 5 Gallon Home Brewing Beer Ingredient Recipe Kit by My Brew Supply

Christmas Ale Advanced All Grain 5 Gallon Home Brewing Beer Ingredient Recipe Kit by My Brew Supply

View on Amazon

Best for: Seasonal beer lovers who want a spiced, full-bodied batch.

Brewers with some all grain experience who want a festive recipe for the colder months will find this kit a good fit.

Pros

  • Complete all grain recipe in one package
  • Rich malt profile suits winter drinking

Cons

  • Spice character may not suit every palate

View on Amazon

Northern Brewer Nut Brown Ale Extract Beer Homebrewing Recipe Kit, 5 Gal

Northern Brewer Nut Brown Ale Extract Beer Homebrewing Recipe Kit, 5 Gal

Northern Brewer Nut Brown Ale Extract Beer Homebrewing Recipe Kit, 5 Gal

View on Amazon

Best for: Extract-curious beginners who want a simpler first brew.

New brewers who want to learn fermentation and sanitation before committing to a full mash will find this kit approachable.

Pros

  • Shorter brew day than all grain
  • Classic, forgiving brown ale recipe

Cons

  • Less control over fermentable sugars than all grain

View on Amazon

Grain Mill Brewing for Grain Malt Barley, Malt Mill for Homebrew Beer

Grain Mill Brewing for Grain Malt Barley, Malt Mill for Homebrew Beer, Grain Crusher Grinder with 7.7LB Hopper 2 Stainless Steel Bearing Rollers and Steel Metal Base, Fit Electric Drill

Grain Mill Brewing for Grain Malt Barley, Malt Mill for Homebrew Beer, Grain Crusher Grinder with 7.7LB Hopper 2 Stainless Steel Bearing Rollers and Steel Metal Base, Fit Electric Drill

View on Amazon

Best for: Brewers who want to crush their own grain for fresher malt.

Brewers who buy base malt in bulk or want to adjust crush size for different mash systems will find a grain mill useful.

Pros

  • Adjustable crush for different brewing methods
  • Stainless rollers and a sturdy base

Cons

  • Needs a drill or motor setup for faster milling

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Batch style and recipe

Check whether the recipe matches the beer you actually want to drink. Hazy IPAs, brown ales and spiced seasonal beers all demand different grain bills and hop schedules.

Included ingredients

Some kits bundle grain, hops and yeast, while others only supply grain. Confirm what is included so you do not have to source missing items mid-brew.

Skill level

Extract kits shorten the brew day, while all grain kits give you more control. Pick the process that matches your current experience and equipment.

Crush and milling

Pre-milled grain is convenient, but a mill lets you control freshness and crush size. Consider this once you have brewed a few batches.

Good picks for this: My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit and Grain Mill Brewing for Grain Malt Barley

FAQ

Do I need a mash tun for all grain beer brewing?

Yes, you need a vessel that holds the grain at a steady mash temperature, such as a cooler converted into a mash tun or a dedicated brewing system.

How long does an all grain brew day take?

Most home brewers plan a full day, including mashing, sparging, boiling and cleanup, though experienced brewers often shorten the process.

Is all grain brewing harder than extract brewing?

It involves more steps and equipment, but many brewers find the added control worth the extra effort once they are comfortable with the basics.

Conclusion

For a complete all grain beer brewing package, the My Brew Supply Hazy IPA kit is a strong fit, while the Christmas Ale kit suits seasonal brewers. Beginners who want a simpler first brew should look at the Northern Brewer extract kit, and anyone wanting fresher malt will benefit from the grain mill.

Sources

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our home brewing guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.