By Graham FisherUpdated November 2026
Finding the right all grain homebrew kit can feel like sorting through a flea market pile of mismatched parts. Every listing promises a great beer, but the details vary: grain bill, hop varieties, yeast strain, batch size and how much work the brew day demands. This list compares seven all grain kits from My Brew Supply, along with the criteria we used to order them: how complete the kit is, whether the recipe suits a beginner or an experienced brewer, the batch size, the hop and yeast quality described on the listing, and how well the style matches common owner feedback about flavor and forgiveness on brew day.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallMy Brew Supply Pacific Coast IPA Brewing Kit | 2-Row Pale Ale Malt | CView on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for big hop flavorMy Brew Supply Double IPA Brewing Kit | 12lbs American Pale 2-Row MaltView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for hazy beer fansMy Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit | American Pale Ale Malt | CarapilView on Amazon - 4
Best for a classic lager-style session beerCream Ale Advanced Homebrew All Grain 5 Gallon Beer Ingredient RecipeView on Amazon - 5
Best for seasonal brewingMy Brew Supply Oktoberfest Beer Ingredient Kit, 5 Gallon All GrainView on Amazon - 6
Best for a lighter, refreshing beerMy Brew Supply American Wheat Brewing Kit | American Wheat & Pilsner MView on Amazon - 7
Best budget pickAmerican Amber Homebrew Beer Ingredient KitView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| My Brew Supply Pacific Coast IPA Brewing Kit | Balanced West Coast-style IPA | Columbus and Chinook hops with a 2-row base |
| My Brew Supply Double IPA Brewing Kit | Bold, strong hop-forward beer | 12 lb American pale 2-row malt and 3 oz Centennial pellet hops |
| My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit | Soft, juicy, hazy IPA | Azacca and Mosaic hops with flaked oats and wheat |
| American Amber Homebrew Beer Ingredient Kit | Budget-minded brewers wanting an amber ale | Malt-forward amber profile |
| Cream Ale Advanced Homebrew All Grain 5 Gallon Kit | Smooth, easy-drinking ales | Light body and gentle hop presence |
| My Brew Supply Oktoberfest Beer Ingredient Kit | Malty autumn lager-style beer | Seasonal, malt-centered recipe |
| My Brew Supply American Wheat Brewing Kit | Refreshing, crisp summer beer | Wheat and pilsner malt base with Kent Goldings and Columbus hops |
My Brew Supply Pacific Coast IPA Brewing Kit | 2-Row Pale Ale Malt | CaraBrown, Biscuit, & Carapils Grain | Columbus & Chinook Hops | American Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing
My Brew Supply Pacific Coast IPA Brewing Kit | 2-Row Pale Ale Malt | CaraBrown, Biscuit, & Carapils Grain | Columbus & Chinook Hops | American Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing
Best for: Balanced West Coast-style IPA with a clean malt backbone
This kit suits brewers who want a classic hop-forward IPA without a heavy, syrupy malt profile. It is a good step up for someone who has already brewed a few extract batches and wants to practice all grain mashing.
Key specs
- 5 gallon batch size
- 2-row pale ale malt base
- Caramel and specialty grains including CaraBrown, Biscuit and Carapils
- Columbus and Chinook hops
- American ale yeast
Pros
- Balanced malt and hop profile suited to a range of palates
- Specialty grains add color and body without overpowering the hops
- Complete kit with grain, hops and yeast included
Cons
- Requires an all grain setup, so it is not suited to brewers without a mash tun
- Hop character is more traditional than the juicy style many newer IPA fans prefer
Bottom line: Pick this kit if you want a dependable, well-rounded IPA and are ready to commit to a full all grain brew day.
My Brew Supply Double IPA Brewing Kit | 12lbs American Pale 2-Row Malt | 1lb Caramel Grain | 3oz Centennial Pellet Hops | American Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing
My Brew Supply Double IPA Brewing Kit | 12lbs American Pale 2-Row Malt | 1lb Caramel Grain | 3oz Centennial Pellet Hops | American Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing
Best for: Bold, high-gravity hop-forward beer for experienced brewers
A double IPA demands more malt and more hops than a standard pale ale, so this kit is aimed at brewers who are comfortable managing a longer boil and a bigger mash.
Key specs
- 5 gallon batch size
- 12 lb American pale 2-row malt
- 1 lb caramel grain
- 3 oz Centennial pellet hops
- American ale yeast
Pros
- Generous grain bill supports a strong, full-bodied beer
- Centennial hops give a classic citrus and pine bitterness
- Clear, straightforward recipe for a big-flavored style
Cons
- Higher gravity can push beginners toward fermentation problems if temperature control is weak
- Limited hop variety compared with more complex recipes
Bottom line: A strong choice for a confident brewer who wants a bold, hoppy beer and has reliable temperature control.
My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit | American Pale Ale Malt | Carapils Grain | Flaked Oats & Wheat | Azacca & Mosaic Pellet Hops | English Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing
My Brew Supply Hazy IPA Brewing Kit | American Pale Ale Malt | Carapils Grain | Flaked Oats & Wheat | Azacca & Mosaic Pellet Hops | English Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing
Best for: Soft, juicy, hazy IPA
Hazy IPA has become one of the most requested styles among homebrewers. This kit uses flaked oats and wheat for body and haze, paired with fruit-forward hops.
Key specs
- 5 gallon batch size
- American pale ale malt with Carapils
- Flaked oats and wheat
- Azacca and Mosaic pellet hops
- English ale yeast
Pros
- Flaked grains help build the soft mouthfeel hazy IPAs are known for
- Azacca and Mosaic deliver tropical and stone-fruit aromas
- Includes everything needed for a full batch
Cons
- Hazy beers are sensitive to oxygen and fermentation temperature, so process discipline matters
- English yeast gives a softer finish that some IPA drinkers may find less crisp
Bottom line: Best for brewers chasing a juicy, cloudy IPA who are careful about oxygen exposure during transfer and dry hopping.
American Amber Homebrew Beer Ingredient Kit
American Amber Homebrew Beer Ingredient Kit
Best for: Budget-minded brewers wanting a malty amber ale
Amber ales are forgiving, malt-driven beers that suit newer brewers. This kit is a practical choice if you want to try a balanced, mid-range style without a large investment.
Key specs
- American amber style
- Malt-forward flavor profile
- Ingredient kit for home brewing
Pros
- Amber styles tolerate small process variations well
- Caramel malt character gives a satisfying, approachable beer
- Good value for a first full kit
Cons
- Listing detail on exact grain and hop specifications is limited, so check before buying
- Less hop intensity than IPA-focused kits
Bottom line: A sensible pick for someone who wants a malty, easy-drinking ale and is watching the budget.
Cream Ale Advanced Homebrew All Grain 5 Gallon Beer Ingredient Recipe Kit by My Brew Supply
Cream Ale Advanced Homebrew All Grain 5 Gallon Beer Ingredient Recipe Kit by My Brew Supply
Best for: Smooth, easy-drinking ale with a light finish
Cream ale is a mild, crisp style that works well for summer drinking and for brewers who want a clean-tasting beer without heavy hop or malt character.
Key specs
- 5 gallon batch size
- Advanced all grain recipe
- Light, smooth ale profile
Pros
- Light body and clean finish make it approachable for most drinkers
- Good stepping stone toward more complex all grain recipes
- Recipe is well suited to fermentation temperature control on a basic setup
Cons
- Subtle flavor may feel plain to brewers who prefer bold styles
- Requires a full all grain brew day, with mash and sparge steps
Bottom line: Pick this kit for a smooth, sessionable beer that is easy to share.
My Brew Supply Oktoberfest Beer Ingredient Kit, 5 Gallon All Grain
My Brew Supply Oktoberfest Beer Ingredient Kit, 5 Gallon All Grain
Best for: Malty, seasonal autumn-style beer
Oktoberfest-style beers are malt-centered and amber in color. This kit suits brewers who enjoy seasonal beers and want to plan a batch ahead of the cooler months.
Key specs
- 5 gallon batch size
- All grain recipe
- Malt-centered seasonal style
Pros
- Rich malt profile with a clean finish
- Seasonal recipe that fits a fall brewing schedule
- Complete all grain kit for a full batch
Cons
- Lager-style beers often benefit from cold conditioning, which requires space and temperature control
- Less suited to brewers who want a hop-driven beer
Bottom line: A good choice for a seasonal, malt-forward beer for brewers with cold storage or a way to control fermentation temperature.
My Brew Supply American Wheat Brewing Kit | American Wheat & Pilsner Malt | Caramel Grain | Kent Goldings & Columbus Pellet Hops | Belgian/German Wheat Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Brewing
My Brew Supply American Wheat Brewing Kit | American Wheat & Pilsner Malt | Caramel Grain | Kent Goldings & Columbus Pellet Hops | Belgian/German Wheat Ale Yeast | 5 Gallon Advanced All Grain Home Bre
Best for: Refreshing, crisp, lighter-bodied beer
Wheat beers are light, refreshing and a good match for warm weather. This kit combines wheat and pilsner malt with a gentle hop addition.
Key specs
- 5 gallon batch size
- American wheat and pilsner malt
- Caramel grain
- Kent Goldings and Columbus pellet hops
- Belgian/German wheat ale yeast
Pros
- Light, refreshing profile suits warm weather
- Wheat yeast adds subtle fruit and spice notes
- Good introduction to a wheat-based recipe
Cons
- Wheat malt can make the mash more difficult to lauter, so a grain bag and careful sparging help
- Low hop character may not satisfy hop lovers
Bottom line: Best for brewers who want a crisp, summer-friendly beer and are comfortable managing a wheat mash.
Buying Guide
Batch size and equipment fit
Every kit on this list makes a 5 gallon batch, which means you need fermentation capacity, a boil kettle large enough for the volume and a mash setup that holds the full grain bill. Check your kettle size and fermenter before you order. For ideas on setting up your space, see Setting Up a Homebrew Space at Home.
Good picks for this: Pacific Coast IPA Brewing Kit, Cream Ale Advanced Homebrew All Grain 5 Gallon Kit
Grain bill and mash complexity
A kit with a large grain bill, like the Double IPA, needs a longer mash and a stronger boil. Wheat-based kits can be harder to sparge. If you are new to mashing, read Mash Equipment Basics: Mash Tuns and Grain Bags before committing to a high-gravity recipe.
Good picks for this: American Wheat Brewing Kit, Oktoberfest Beer Ingredient Kit
Hop variety and aroma
Hop choice shapes the beer more than almost any other ingredient. Citrus and tropical varieties like Azacca and Mosaic give bright, fruity aroma, while Centennial and Columbus bring bitterness and resin. Match the hop profile to the style you want rather than picking by name alone.
Good picks for this: Hazy IPA Brewing Kit, Double IPA Brewing Kit
Yeast type
Yeast strain affects flavor, clarity and fermentation speed. American ale yeast gives a clean, neutral character suited to most IPAs. English ale yeast leaves more malt sweetness and body, which suits hazy styles. Wheat ale yeast adds subtle esters. Choose the yeast that matches your target style.
Good picks for this: Hazy IPA Brewing Kit, American Wheat Brewing Kit
Skill level and process demands
All grain brewing adds mashing, lautering and sparging to the brew day. That takes more time and more equipment than extract brewing. For a beginner-friendly path, see Homebrew Brewing Systems: Extract, BIAB and All-Grain, which compares the three main approaches.
Good picks for this: American Amber Homebrew Beer Ingredient Kit, Cream Ale Advanced Homebrew All Grain 5 Gallon Kit
Water and fermentation control
Water chemistry and fermentation temperature both affect the finished beer. Hazy IPAs and lagers are especially sensitive. A basic water test helps you understand your brewing water, and you can read more in Homebrew Water Test Kit: How to Test and Adjust Your Brewing Water.
Good picks for this: Hazy IPA Brewing Kit, Oktoberfest Beer Ingredient Kit
Use case and style goals
Think about the beers you drink most often. If you want a session beer for the patio, a wheat or cream ale fits. If you want a bold, hoppy beer for friends, an IPA or double IPA makes more sense. A kit that matches your personal taste is more likely to keep you brewing.
Good picks for this: Pacific Coast IPA Brewing Kit, American Wheat Brewing Kit
FAQ
What is an all grain homebrew kit?
An all grain kit includes the malted grain, hops, yeast and specialty ingredients needed to brew a beer from raw grain. You mash the grain in hot water to extract sugars, then boil, cool, ferment and package the beer. It differs from an extract kit, which uses pre-made malt extract.
Do I need special equipment for an all grain kit?
Yes. You need a mash tun or a grain bag system, a boil kettle large enough for the full volume, a way to chill the wort quickly and a fermenter with an airlock. Many brewers start with a braided mash bag in a large kettle.
How long does an all grain brew day take?
Most brewers allow roughly five to seven hours from setup to cleanup for a 5 gallon batch, though this varies with equipment and experience. Fermentation and conditioning take additional weeks.
Which kit is best for a beginner?
Kits with a moderate grain bill and forgiving styles, such as the Cream Ale or American Amber, are often recommended for newer all grain brewers. Hazy IPA and double IPA styles demand more process control.
How long does the beer take to be ready to drink?
Ales typically need two to three weeks of fermentation and one to two weeks of conditioning. Hazy IPAs are often best consumed fresh. Lagers, like Oktoberfest, need extended cold conditioning. Always confirm with your gravity readings, and see How to Use a Hydrometer for Homebrew for guidance.
Can I use these kits for extract brewing?
These listings are designed for all grain brewing. Extract brewers would need to use a different recipe or convert the grain bill, which requires experience.
Are these kits suitable for gluten-free brewing?
No. All of these kits contain barley or wheat malt. For gluten-free options, see 8 Best Gluten Free Homebrew Kit Options for Beginners (2026).
Conclusion
For a balanced, well-rounded IPA, the Pacific Coast IPA kit is a strong all-around choice. Brewers chasing a bold, hop-forward beer should look at the Double IPA, while the Hazy IPA suits fans of juicy, cloudy styles. If you prefer lighter, easy-drinking beers, the Cream Ale and American Wheat kits are the better fit. The Oktoberfest kit suits seasonal malt lovers, and the American Amber is a sensible pick for a budget-minded first full batch. Match the style to your taste, your equipment and your willingness to manage fermentation, and you will get a result you enjoy.
Sources
- Grain and malt quality information relevant to brewing ingredients (usda.gov)
- Food safety guidance on sanitation and fermentation hygiene (cdc.gov)
- Consumer product safety information for home equipment such as kettles and burners (cpsc.gov)
About Graham Fisher
Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our home brewing guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.
